Sarcodonin G, one of the cyathane diterpenoids isolated from the mushroom Sarcodon scabrosus, possesses pronounced neurotrophic activity but ambiguous mechanical understanding. In this work, sarcodonin G was chosen as a lead compound to prepare a series of 19-O-benzoyl derivatives by semisynthesis and their neuritogenic activities were evaluated. 6 and 15 (10 μM), were investigated with opposite effects in PC12 cells. 6 exhibited a superior activity to sarcodonin G by promoting NGF-induced neurite outgrowth, while 15 showed an inhibitory effect. Supportingly, 6 and 15 (20 μM) significantly induced and suppressed neurite extension in primary cultured rat cortical neurons, respectively. In mechanism, the two derivatives were revealed to influence NGF-induced neurite outgrowth in PC12 cells through the regulation of PKC-dependent and -independent ERK/CREB signaling as well as the upstream TrkA receptor phosphorylation. Furthermore, a possible pattern of interaction among NGF, 6/15 and TrkA was presented using molecular simulations. It revealed that 6/15 may contribute to the stabilization of the NGF-TrkAd5 complex by establishing several hydrophobic and hydrogen-bond interactions with NGF and TrkA, respectively. Taken together, 6 and 15 modulate PKC-dependent and -independent Erk/CREB signaling pathways possibly by influencing the binding affinity of NGF to the receptor TrkA, and finally regulate neurite outgrowth in PC12 cells.